| Author |
Cavite State University Student Incident |
 artUP
Lord of the Threads
Joined: Nov 2005
| 2006-04-28 12:50
a certain peyups user informed me about this incident and requested me to put up this topic (probie pa lang kasi siya e)
its about a graduating female student who heckled at GMA ata or something. anyone who knows about this incident?
sori kung may nakagawa na ng same thread. pakilock na lang po. 
-----------------
It's not what you have achieved. It's who you have become.
|
|
|
 wanderer
Posting Expert
Joined: Nov 2001
| 2006-04-28 13:01
it is political speech and should be protected by the courts.
-----------------
to know what is right and choose to ignore it is the act of a coward.
|
 Glennpogi
Peyups Addict
Joined: Dec 2005
| 2006-04-28 13:15
Eto ba yung binabanggit mo ?
Gonzalez orders NBI to investigate graduate
First posted 02:11am (Mla time) April 26, 2006
By Leila B. Salaverria
Inquirer
JUSTICE SECRETARY Raul Gonzalez said a crime had been committed when a graduating student stood up, unfurled a banner and called for President Macapagal-Arroyo's ouster during graduation rites at the Cavite State University in Indang, Cavite, last week.Editor's Note: Published on Page A1 of the April 26, 2006 issue of the Philippine Daily Inquirer
Gonzalez ordered an investigation of mass communications graduate Maria Theresa Pangilinan who heckled Ms Arroyo as she was delivering her commencement address.
In a memorandum, he also directed the National Bureau of Investigation to identify the other people who had raised banners calling for Ms Arroyo to step down, determine the possible involvement of university officials in the incident, and to find out how the protesters were able to enter the school premises.
Interview reporters
"Gather information and sufficient evidence for the possible filing of charges against those persons," Gonzalez said.
He also directed the NBI to interview Inquirer reporters Gil Cabacungan Jr. and Marlon Ramos and Philippine Star reporter Aurea Calica in the course of their investigation. The heckling incident took place last Saturday as the President was delivering her speech at the CavSU graduation. Pangilinan then stood up and shouted "Patalsikin si (Oust) Gloria" and unfurled a banner declaring "No to Cha-cha."
Moments later, several people belonging to the Bagong Alyansang Makabayan and the Solidarity of Cavite Workers also held up banners calling for the President to step down. They shouted their demand for Ms Arroyo's ouster as they were being led by the Presidential Security Group out of the venue.
Gonzalez said he was not asked by the President to order the investigation, but that he did it on his own initiative.
"As far as I'm concerned, a crime was committed," he told reporters.
He said the protesters violated Article 153 of the Revised Penal Code, which penalizes those who "cause any serious disturbance in a public place, office, or establishment, or shall interrupt or disturb public performances, functions or gatherings, or peaceful meetings."
Other violations
Gonzalez said the protesters also violated Article 154, which penalizes those "who by the same means, or by words, utterances or speeches shall encourage disobedience to the law or to the constituted authorities or praise, justify or extol any act punished by law."
He said the offenses carried a penalty of six months to two years in prison.
Gonzalez also said the presence of Ms Arroyo at the graduation rites aggravated any criminal liability.
He said one of the aggravating circumstance listed under Article 14 was "that the crime be committed in the palace of the Chief Executive or in his presence, or where public authorities are engaged in the discharge of their duties."
Gonzalez was not the first of the President's men to come to her aid after the heckling incident.
The President's Chief of Staff Michael Defensor earlier said there was a need for the PSG to tighten security.
He also said the university's officials were to blame for the heckling since they were the ones who invited Ms Arroyo to be their guest.
so meron tayong pekeng presidente at ulol na SC Justice...what a combo !!!
-----------------
Paintball tayo !!!!???
|
 Chihiro
Peyups Addict
Joined: Nov 2003
| 2006-04-28 14:04
^ Di SC justice si Gonzales (well, not yet anyway, but I know that's what he wants to be when grows up) pero tama ka - ulol nga sya.
-----------------
Hello...Garci?
Weather-weather lang yan....
|
 jasper_cool
Lord of the Threads
Joined: Dec 2002
| 2006-04-28 14:51
noong nabalitaan ko yung ginawa nung isang graduate ng CSU... medyo natuwa ako pero napaisip ako... bakit sa graduation? kahit hindi kagalang galang si Gloria at least yung babae nag protest should respect yung mga ibang graduates at mga parents kasi napaka special na araw iyon para sa mga grumaduate. There would be always a proper time for that.. sana tinapos na lang niya yung graduation bago nila ginawa yun..
kay Dept. of Injustice este Justice Sec. Gonzales.. naku naman ang daming problems ang bansa natin wag niyo ng sakayan niyan.. hindi ko malaman kay Sec. Gonzales pag may issue.. sumasawsaw.. Diyos ko po.. marami pang masmalaking issues na dapat bigyan tuon kaysa dito..
-----------------
Getting sad is inevitable but being happy is an option.
|
 Soo-young
Posting Expert
Joined: Nov 2002
| 2006-04-28 14:57
may proper time naman for that.
sinira niya yung special day ng ibang tao. 
eh kung ayaw niya kay GMA, ba't pa siya nakipagkamay?
-----------------
there are only 2 kinds of education in this world:
one is, how to make a living... and the other one is, how to live.
|
 snowprincess
Forum Resident
Joined: Dec 2005
| 2006-04-28 16:08
Naisip ko din na mali dahil hindi na niya nirespeto ang presidente. Naturingan pa man din siyang nakapag-aral, to think na graduating pa man din siya. O kung ayaw man niya kay Gloria, sana nga nirespeto niya yung okasyon. Graduation yun. Yung ang pinakatuktok ng mga pangarap ng bawat estudyante at mga magulang nung mga nag graduate. Sisirain niya lang sa pamamagitan ng paninigaw sa presidente.
Matapang nga siya, pero wala siya sa lugar. Hindi lamang puro katapangan ang kailangan. Natapakan na niya yung karapatan ng iba para sa maayos at tahimik na graduation rites. Mali na yun.
|
 malek
Forum Resident
Joined: Nov 2003
| 2006-04-28 19:14
sa tingin ko naman lahat ng bagay ay dapat ilagay sa tamang panahon at tamang lugar. kung ayaw niya kay GMA, walang pumipilit sa kanya. kaya lang sana inisip muna niya kung anong klaseng okasyon yung ginulo niya at kung sino-sino ba ang mga taong naapektuhan niya. ang pinakita niyang asal kasi, para sa akin, ay isang simbolo ng kabastusan, kawalan ng galang sa ibang tao, at kakulangan ng pinag-aralan. kung gusto niyang magsisisigaw, sumama siya sa rally sa May 1, para kahit papano rally yun, ok lang mag-ingay.
-----------------
***The STAR is the limit***
|
 Elcavitenyo
Active Member
Joined: Apr 2006
| 2006-04-28 22:01
don't mess around with our probinsya! duyan ng mga magiting!
|
 wastedlyf
Honorary Member
Joined: Oct 2002
| 2006-04-28 22:55
hmm, di ko alam kung dun galing si Heneral Makapagal. Yung Heneral na naki-connive na patayin si Bonifacio.
magiting nga ***y*** naman! 
-----------------
mukhang adik man ako sa iyong paningin, tumingin ka lang sa akin, maaadik ka rin.
|
 ErwinRafael
Lord of the Threads
Joined: Nov 2002
| 2006-04-29 10:20
pero bakit ganun? nung binastos ni Ed Jopson si Marcos nang harap-harapan, pinuri pa siya? tapos nung hindi nagsiattend ng graduation ang maraming UP students noong 1998 dahil ayaw nila kay Erap, bakit hindi ginawang malaking isyu?
double standards?
-----------------
Dalawin ang aking tambayan
|
 bicbic
Active Member
Joined: Apr 2006
| 2006-04-30 01:37
malaki ang pagkakaiba ng pagiging matapang (which she claims herself to be) at pagiging walang modo, walang urbanidad at pagiging bastos.
she thinks she's heroic on what she did, na parang sya ang boses ng kanyang henerasyon. she could have done that on the streets, but on her graduation??
napaka-cinematic nya. sa movies at tv nya lang siguro napapanod ang ganon, tapos in-apply nya into reality. i don't think any sane student (or person) would have done anything like that. mas luka-luka pa sya kay miriam!
and now she's famous, with all those encouraging words from the opposition! kapag nagpagamit sya sa mga yun, nagpa-"politika" na din sya.
she's enjoying so much of her fame!
she's simply insane. 
and to elcavitenyo, ano ba talagang opinion mo?
taga-dun ka pa man din!
-----------------
hindi ako yoyo
na pwede mong basta na lang ihagis-hilahin.
|
wanderer
Posting Expert
Joined: Nov 2001
| 2006-04-30 09:40
but i agree that she could've picked a better time to voice her displeasure of the president. yung weird dun nakipagkamay pa sya afterwards... ngek.
as for gonzales, i still don't know what's up with the guy. parang sobrang ingrained na sa kanya ang pagiging lapdog/defender kuno ni gma na naging sobrang trigger happy na sya.
-----------------
to know what is right and choose to ignore it is the act of a coward.
|
Chihiro
Peyups Addict
Joined: Nov 2003
| 2006-04-30 11:57
di sya naging bastos imo. tama lang ang ginawa nya. i would have done the same thing, if not taken it to the next level.
-----------------
Hello...Garci?
Weather-weather lang yan....
|
 samhain13
Forum Resident
Joined: May 2002
| 2006-04-30 16:22
I read Winnie Monsod's opinion on the incident yesterday in her column, I have to say I fully agree with it-- and with most opinions here. Wala sa lugar at sana nirespeto naman nung bata yung okasyon. For the attendees-- parents and students--, it was the culmination of a lot of hard work and they all deserve to celebrate that moment regardless of who the guest is because that special moment wasn't about the guest but about them. And one person ruined that moment.
Wala lang. 
-----------------
[This message was edited by samhain13 on 2006-04-30 16:24]
|
